Lommasson Center 154
Missoula, MT 59812
FAQs for Modifications
What are reasonable modifications?
Civil rights laws require reasonable modifications of non-essential elements of academic programs in order to ensure access. These modifications only change in the learning environment that permit students with disabilities to compete on an equal footing with their peers at the University.
Students with disabilities must meet or exceed academic standards with or without reasonable modifications. Under no circumstances should any modification result in a fundamental alteration to a class.
When should students request modifications from their instructors?
Disability Services encourages students to request modifications early in the semester. Students are also advised by Disability Services to make an appointment with the instructor in advance. However, be aware that this is not always the case. Retroactive modification requests do not have to be honored.
What if the student’s modification requests differ from what a verification letter recommends?
What should instructors do when students say their disabilities limit attendance or meeting deadlines?
Class attendance and assignment policies are set by faculty or departments. When the functional limitations of the disability affect a student’s participation in his/her classes, the student’s Disability Services coordinator may recommend flexibility with attendance and deadline policies as a possible reasonable modification.
However, flexibility with attendance and deadline policies may not be reasonable if class participation is determined as an essential component of the class.
Instructors do not have to grant retroactive modification requests from students.
When requesting extended deadlines, students must to notify the instructors before the due date and make arrangements with the instructor to determine the new due date. The extended deadlines should not compromise the integrity of the course.
Instructors determine policies about make-up work, missed quizzes and exams. The instructors have the right to hold to their academic standards and are not required to lower or modify essential course elements to provide modifications to students with disabilities.
Discussion between the instructor and the student is essential. Disability Services coordinators are available to participate in such discussions.
What do instructors do when a student asks for a notetaker in class?
Students with disabilities, who qualify for notetaking services, will ask classmates to share notes with them. However, if the search is not successful, the students may ask you for your assistance by making an announcement in the class.
An example of the announcement is: “A student with a disability is looking for a volunteer notetaker in this class. The notetaker will receive a stipend of $30 in UMoney per semester from Disability Services. Please see me after class for more information.”
How do instructors request a sign language interpreter?
What if a classroom is moved?
What if a student misses class because of an elevator breakdown?
Are modifications fair to other students?
Civil rights laws for people with disabilities are founded on the assumption: the same treatment does not always fairly measure. The laws protect students with disabilities from being subjected to the arbitrary measure of what is best for others, except in cases of safety to others. The assumption of the law is that modifying non-essential tasks should give students with disabilities an equal, or fair, chance to demonstrate their ability by minimizing their functional limitations to the greatest extent possible.
A student, with writing or typing limitations, may be an excellent writer even though he/she cannot print or type the letters and words. Thus, the physical act of writing is a non-essential task. The student's mastery of language and course material must not, under the law, be judged by his/her ability to manipulate a pencil or pen, or use a keyboard. Providing a scribe to record the student's essay responses permits the student to show whether he/she can write effectively, and if the student has acquired the information and critical skills the instructor wished to convey in the course.
No unfair advantage over nondisabled peers is gained by the use of a scribe. In using this auxiliary aid, the student must communicate clearly to the scribe the words and structure of his/her answer -- including punctuation and spelling. Even with extended time on an essay exam to compensate for the additional time of dictating to the scribe, the student can only hope for equality of access.
How do instructors challenge a modification that they feel unreasonable?
If you are uncertain about a request for a modification, you can challenge the student's request in a number of ways. First, ask the student to provide a verification letter from Disability Services to ensure that the modification is recommended by Disability Services. If the letter does not mention a requested modification, please contact Disability Services. The modification is considered unreasonable if it reduces the academic standards or requirements for a given course. It is also unreasonable if it is impossible to administer. If a modification does not appear to be appropriate given the student's functional limitation, Disability Services will not support it.
Students may request modifications that have not been discussed with Disability Services. This does not always mean that the request is unreasonable under the law. Contact Disability Services if a request seems to be unreasonable. We will work with instructors to suggest other alternatives to the student.
If you decide to deny a request as unreasonable, consult your colleagues in your department and inform the student clearly of your reasons for the denial of the request. If you have discussed this with Disability Services already, refer the student to his/her coordinator for further clarification.
What do instructors do to deny students' modification requests?
The University is responsible for providing modifications unless they fall under one of the following three categories:
Disability Services recommends that denials of modification requests based on a fundamental alteration be decided at least at the departmental level and not by an individual instructor. Instructors and their departments should feel free to negotiate modifications that best fit course expectations. Contact Disability Services for further information.