The Center for Ethics Homepage
.: UM Home .: search .: A-Z index
Debating Science logo
Debating Science | nanotechnology | biotechnology | climate change
Thomas Hart Benton.  Wheat.   Smithsonian American Art Museum,  Gift of Mr. and Mrs. James A. Mitchell and museum purchase

 

 

 

Debating Science and The Biotechnology Debate

Traditionally there has been little formal effort through coursework to bridge the gap between scientific research and social debates arising from the ethical implications of technological innovations. Consequently, specialists are more comfortable within their area of expertise. But in the case of biotechnology, the forces driving research are so strong and the public’s lack of knowledge so great that society needs scientists to cross the gap between scientific discourse and public debate. Scientists need to become productive participants in the arena of ethical deliberation.

It is equally important for scientists to understand that biotechnology is not only a research problem. The articulation of an appropriate biotechnology policy will require negotiation among international participants who have different interests and needs. If the process by which an acceptable policy is reached must be fair and democratic, then these normative concepts must also play an important role in the process. Because of this, scientists need to understand how scientific findings can appropriately be incorporated into public debate about issues, and must be prepared to situate scientific considerations within a democratic public debate.

This course is designed to help address this need. It entails in-depth study of the international debate over agricultural biotechnology.

* Full Syllabus
* Participant Application

We are no longer taking applications, check back next January to apply for the Debating Science 2008 or see our Environmental Ethics Institute for other course opportunities

Instructors
Dane Scott (webpage)
Dane Scott Dane Scott is Director of the Center for Ethics at The University of Montana and Associate Professor of Environmental Studies. He became interested in debates over science and technology while studying the international debate over genetically modified organisms. Since 2001, these studies have produced several publications and professional presentations in the United States and Europe. Dr. Scott is currently completing a book dealing with practical reasoning, precaution and the biotechnology debate. These interests also led Dr. Scott to team-teach a course on ethics and biotechnology with biologist Jim Costa. In addition, Dr. Scott has taught several courses on practical reasoning and ethical dialogue, including a graduate course at the University of Montana focusing on ethical reasoning and the biotechnology debate in 2006. Dr. Scott holds a B.S. in Soil Science from the University of California at Riverside, an MA from the Graduate Theological Union in Berkeley, CA and a Ph.D. in Philosophy from Vanderbilt University. When not working, Scott is out riding his mountain bike, skiing, hiking or climbing in the beautiful mountains surrounding Missoula.

Jim Costa (webpage)

Jim CostaJames T. Costa is Executive Director of the Highlands Biological Station in Highlands, North Carolina, and is H. F. and Katherine P. Robinson Professor of Biology at Western Carolina University, where he has taught genetics, evolution, entomology, biogeography, forensic biology, and bioethics (the last co-developed with Dr. Dane Scott) since 1996. In 2004-2005 he was the Jeanne Rousselet Fellow at the Radcliffe Institute for Advanced Study, Harvard University, and has a long-standing appointment as Associate Research Fellow at Harvard's Museum of Comparative Zoology. Dr. Costa's primary research interest is mechanisms of communication and cooperation in social insects, and the ecology of social evolution. He uses caterpillar, sawfly, and beetle societies as model systems in both field and laboratory-based genetic and behavioral experiments sited in North America, Costa Rica, and Mexico. He has a parallel interest in the history and philosophy of science, in particular the development of evolutionary thinking, the conceptual history of insect sociobiology, and the ethical dimensions of biotechnology. In addition to numerous scientific papers, Dr. Costa is the author of The Other Insect Societies, forthcoming May 2006 from Harvard University Press, a book that provides the first synthesis of behavioral, ecological, and evolutionary research on social behavior in a broad cross section of insects and related groups. He has also participated in a range of scientific outreach programs, including seminars on evolution, forensic biology, and genetically modified foods for the North Carolina Center for the Advancement of Teaching, the North Carolina Dietetic Society, and the North Carolina Criminal Justice Association. He annually co-teaches a summer course on Darwin and evolution at the University of Oxford, England, in connection with his latest book project, a reader's guide to the Origin of Species. As Executive Director of the Highlands Biological Station, Dr. Costa is keenly interested in expanding the Station's already extensive educational programming to include bioethical aspects of environmental science, biodiversity, and biotechnology.
| Application | Workshop | Courses | CfE Home |
We are no longer taking applications, check back next January to apply for the Debating Science 2008 or see our Environmental Ethics Institute for other course opportunities

About us | Courses | Programs | Environmental Ethics Institute | Resources | Consulting

The Center for Ethics | 1000 East Beckwith | The University of Montana | Missoula, MT 59812-2808 | (406) 243-5744 | (406) 243-6633, fax | ethics@mso.umt.edu

|| :: Revised: January, 2007 :: ||

Frontpiece image:

Thomas Hart Benton
Wheat
Smithsonian American Art Museum,
Gift of Mr. and Mrs. James A. Mitchell and museum purchase
http://americanart.si.edu

website by Justin Whitaker