Review Process & Selection Criteria
Proposals for all UGP grants will be evaluated by the University Research and Creativity Committee (URCC. The URCC will make funding recommendations to the Vice President for Research and Creative Scholarship. Applicants will be advised of final funding decisions in April 2027. For general questions about proposal review, contact URCC Chair Fernando Sánchez (Fernando.Sanchez@mso.umt.edu).
The committee will use the following review criteria to assess proposals.
Significance and Potential Impact
The significance and potential impact of the project for the relevant field is clearly demonstrated. The URCC will consider:
- The potential contribution of the proposed project to increased knowledge or understanding within the relevant field.
- The likelihood that the proposed project will result in improvements to teaching, practice, or research.
Project Plan and Approach
The soundness of the project plan, approach, and, if applicable, research methodology is thoroughly addressed. Additionally, reviewers will consider the extent to which the application includes a workplan that describes the project timeline, milestones, and the proposed strategy for implementing and managing the project.
Ideally, your project should not rely on other pending projects. A failure or unexpected result from the other project could negatively impact your ability to complete your UGP project. Requests for major changes to your scope of work under such circumstances are unlikely to be approved.
Evaluation/Outcomes (Measures of Success)
The plans to evaluate project results, including deliverables (presentations, performances, publications, etc.), key dependent measures/outcomes, and reach to the community or relevant field, are appropriate, feasible, and clearly described.
Applicant Capacity for Project Success
Whether qualifications, expertise, and relevant accomplishments of the PI and key personnel (if applicable) demonstrates capacity to carry out the activities for which support is requested. May include a description of relevant publications, performances, exhibitions, etc.
Future Plans
The URCC will consider plans for future papers, exhibits, performances, presentations, or other similar outputs.
Budget Justification
The proposed budget is reasonable in relation to the objectives, the complexity of the proposed activities, and the anticipated results.
Please note that reviewers do not expect a detailed budget at the time of application. If a project is awarded, the awardee will work with their OSP pre-award specialist to fine-tune the budget.
The following is provided as an example only. Applicants are not expected to use this as a template.
I am requesting $5,000 in total to support [project name/goal].
Supplies ($750): Funds will purchase [supply type, e.g., research materials and software licenses] needed to complete [specific project activity].
Travel ($3,000): Funds will cover registration, airfare, lodging, and per diem for [one team member] to present project findings at [Conference Name], which will [disseminate results/build partnerships].
Meeting Costs ($1,250): Funds will cover room rental, materials, and refreshments for [X] project meetings with [partners/stakeholders], at roughly $[X] per meeting.
All costs are necessary and reasonable for achieving the project’s goals.